D&D Next Character Creation

When I first read through the new playtest materials I started getting excited. It looked like I was finally going to be able to make Brianna Sheàri, the female protagonist of the series of short stories I’ve been working on over the past several years.

She started life as a Wood Elf Ranger in Champions of Norrath years and years ago. I later used her name for an elf ranger in a HackMaster 4e campaign. After that I started writing her story.

She has largely kept the ranger theme: her skills are primarily focused on archery and wood lore, and she has some access to both elemental (mostly by enchanting arrows on the fly) and healing magic (infusing into healing poultices after applying them). The details of those skills have changed as my world has developed (for instance, elves, orcs, and humans are all different types of humans instead of distinct races), but that’s enough to be getting on with.

Naturally, I can only truly make her in GURPS, and have done so, but I’m forever trying to shoehorn her into various class-based games just to see how close I can get. So far I have only managed it by focusing on one aspect of her character and ignoring others. In D&D Encounters she is a Hunter Ranger. That gives her the forest survival and hunting skills, as well as the marksmanship, but complete ignores her magic side.

Then came the new playtest and it looked like I might finally be able to make Brianna in a class-based game. I started with High Elf since it gives her a free wizard cantrip, and made her a Fighter with the Sharpshooter Fighting Style. To gain her herbalism and healing magic I added the Healer Specialization. It gives her the ability to make healing potions and healer’s kits. I can easily flavor those as using the combination of herbalism and healing magic she uses in my book.

That left me with two unsolved issues: neither of her cantrip choices were reasonably re-flavored into her ability to ignite arrows as they leave her bow, and she didn’t yet have any skills beyond the ability to shoot and heal. Looking at the skill list, she needs Natural Lore, Survival, Spot, and Stealth for her ranger skills, and Magical Lore to finish her off.

The first problem I can solve by simply adapting Ray of Frost into a fire attack, or devising a new spell that lets her spend her action to add extra fire damage to her next bow attack.

The second problem is harder. As in the first playtest, skills are gained via Backgrounds, but unlike before all backgrounds now yield exactly three skills, no more, no less. Each also includes a Trait that gives things like owning a house and plot of land somewhere, knowing where to find a piece of information you can’t call to mind, or having contacts in various places and organizations.

Not surprisingly, the included list of backgrounds is short so it can’t possibly cover every possible combination of skills, but I can’t find one that’s remotely suitable for Brianna. For one thing, the only background that includes Survival is Soldier (which bundles in Intimidate and Spot) and the trait gives you a military rank, which is likely not at all useful to the majority of characters that want that combination of skills.

In 4e, included backgrounds were suggestions to give you an idea of the things they can do, with the assumption that you would make up your own (which I do with nearly every character). The playtest likewise calls them “Sample Backgrounds” so I expect there will be guidelines for making your own eventually, but if they’re all “Pick three skills and make up a fluff Trait” then I’ll pass.

As far as I can tell, the only way to have more than three skills is to take the specialty that gives you the Skill Training feat at first and third levels, but that prevents you from taking far more interesting specialties instead.

At that point my balloon of excitement popped. Adding further to my disappointment is that skills are now tied to attributes again. Their separation was brilliant and one of the things I loved best  about the original playtest.

It makes me wonder why they don’t adapt D&D 3.x’s skill points instead of being so restrictive with skills. Even better would be following HackMaster’s example and go full-on hybrid point-buy – but I’m not holding my breath.

So here’s the short version: I’m loving D&D 5e so far, except for backgrounds and skills. Those two things are very in the way of me enjoying the system.


7 thoughts on “D&D Next Character Creation

  1. Pingback: Taking D&D Basic for a Spin | Frankly Speaking

  2. tedluck

    Wizards is releasing a podcast they did with Penny Arcade in which Mike Mearls goes over some of the early character building stuff. From that it sounded very much like you could pull various skills from different backgrounds to suit your character concept if you couldn’t find a background that matched what you wanted. More of a cherry picking than having to take the whole thing as is. I expect there to be a lot more backgrounds and themes and development continues as well, eventually encompassing a lot more character concepts.

    It’s very interesting to me how you have a complete concept that you try to adapt to new types of systems. You see backgrounds as things to mold to what you have imagined. Whereas I, being less creative, might look to the backgrounds provided to help me shape a character. Both are legitimate ways of making a character, and my hope is that DnD Next will accommodate us both.


  3. Frank Wilcox


    I like the character concept, and think that you should be fine to fluff what you need within the rules. The other, less fun, option is to just create the closest approximation you can and pump the xp into making it the character you wan to play.

    Glad you like her. Being the protagonist in three short stories so far, I’ve gotten to know her pretty well. So far fluffing or making do are what I’ve always had to do in order to play her in class-based games. I was really hoping that maybe I wouldn’t have to for once.

    It would be easier if I wasn’t a writer. Unlike the vast majority of roleplayers I’ve ever talked with, with very rare exceptions I don’t make my characters – they live in my head and tell me about themselves. My writer friends (and fellow gamer and writer I married a decade ago) understand perfectly since they experience the same thing, but I have yet to successfully explain it to anyone else. Whenever I post a character someone will inevitably ask something like: “Why don’t you use weapon X instead? It’s much better.” My equally inevitable response goes, “Because she wouldn’t use it”, and then the insults begin. I finally quit posting non-GURPS characters.

    Big fan of archers in RPGs at the moment, so I thought I’d share this with you. http://shortymonster.wordpress.com/2012/07/30/to-be-an-archer-3/

    Thanks. That was really interesting. Nothing we didn’t know since we’re such history geeks, but we both found it fascinating nonetheless.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s